What are
the problems with air pollution and is it connected to climate change?
There has been some confusion about climate change. Here is an analysis
of the evidence for climate change and its consequences with some
possible actions that could be taken to reduce the damage of climate
change.
In reality, there are two problems with air pollution. The
simplest is air pollution by trace gasses. Here, small amounts of
dangerous gasses (usually acids) are released in a chemical reaction,
usually combustion. These gasses have a bad impact on the environment
and must be eliminated. A good example is sulfur in coal. The sulfur in
coal is oxidized by combustion inside a power plant and is washed out of
the atmosphere by rain, making "acid rain". When enough acid rain is
formed, it starts killing plants and fish. These pollution problems are
readily traced and are usually not controversial. What is controversial
is how to get rid of the pollution. Usually a procedure can be found,
but it may be expensive. This problem will not be addressed further
here.
The more complex problem is air pollution that causes a
composition change in the atmosphere. This is exemplified by the
increase in atmospheric carbon dioxide and methane and its impact on
earth's average temperature. The theory and the best data indicate that
if too much carbon dioxide and methane (greenhouse gasses) get into the
air, they capture the visible radiation, hold the infrared radiation and
change the earth's heat balance. This raises the average temperature of
the earth's atmosphere, and so it is called global warming.
One
thing that makes this theory controversial is that all fossil fuels
generate carbon dioxide when burned, and the vast majority of our energy
is obtained by burning fossil fuels, so it is very difficult (and
expensive) to reduce the amount of carbon dioxide that is emitted.
Therefore, there is a very strong motive to disbelieve this theory.
Another
problem is that the earth has climate zones that move with average
temperature, so the zone position changes as the average temperature
increases. Thus at any earth position, the temperature may be increasing
(due to global warming) or decreasing (due to zone position movement).
Critics ask which trend they should believe. The answer, of course, is
that it is the average of the temperatures in all climate zones that
determines the average earth temperature. This average cannot be
determined by a measurement in only one earth position and so it is
still being argued.
A third thing that makes this global warming
controversial is the impact it may have on the earth's livability. It
may not be possible to just wait for the effects to become clear and
then take action. We may have to decide on an action plan now.
If indeed the earth is warming, then several things will happen:
- The
earth's glaciers and ice caps will be reduced, and eventually
disappear. Less of the visible radiation on the earth will be reflected
into space, and more will be captured which will tend to increase the
earth's average temperature. Also, some of the ocean's most productive
zones are under ice, so loss of ice may result in a loss in the ocean's
fish production.
- The melted ice will raise the mean sea level and low-lying land will
be submerged. If so, some of the most important and valuable real
estate in the world will be submerged.
- The climate zones will move north in the northern hemisphere (or
south in the southern hemisphere) and some old fertile agriculture zones
will dry up and some new zones will be waterlogged. The consensus is
that there will be a net loss of agricultural area.
- The oceans will warm and spread. This will kill many reefs in the
ocean and cypress forests on the edge of the ocean where fish breed with
a resulting loss of fish production. Hurricanes will also increase in
strength.
- The aerosols in the earth's atmosphere (fog, dust, ice particles,
sulfur dioxide, etc) will change. An increase will increase the amount
of visible radiation reflected by the atmosphere, and this could
decrease the amount of radiation absorbed by the atmosphere. Most
experts expect an aerosol increase, and a resultant reduction in solar
absorption.
- Most important, the permafrost in the arctic is expected to melt.
This will cause the vegetation frozen in this layer to decompose and
emit methane and carbon dioxide that would raise the temperature more.
Thus the warming caused by man would cause more warming caused by
nature.
Until now, mankind put carbon dioxide and
methane into the atmosphere, and warming started. If stopped a new
equilibrium would form and the warming would stop, but at a higher
average temperature. There are processes that absorb the new carbon
dioxide and aid the formation of this equilibrium. Two of the most
important of these processes are forest growth and carbonate rock
formation by plankton. Clearly mankind is overwhelming these processes,
because the carbon dioxide content of the atmosphere is growing rapidly.
Part of this problem is that mankind is cutting the forests, but
largest part of the problem is the greenhouse gasses from fossil fuels.
In
the future, if mankind reduces his carbon dioxide contribution enough
to drop below the natural absorption capability, there will be at least
two warming processes that still grow-the loss of the reflectivity of
ice at the poles, and the carbon dioxide and methane production by
decomposing permafrost vegetation. If the effect of these processes
rises above that of the natural absorption processes, the warming trend
will continue without mankind's contribution. This automatic temperature
increase is called runaway warming. The only way to stop runaway
warming is to provide a new means of removing carbon dioxide from the
atmosphere.
The Evidence
The evidence shows the following trends:
- Some
areas show a warming trend and some show cooling. A computer model is
required to interpret the data because climate zones are shifting as
well as warming. Generally, however, warming trends seem to dominate.
- The glaciers and ice caps are melting.
- The melted ice does appear to be raising the mean sea level;
although this measurement is more controversial. The mean sea level
appears different at different earth positions.
- The climate zones are moving north in the northern hemisphere (and
south in the southern hemisphere). This results in desertification in
some productive agricultural areas and waterlogging in others.
- The oceans are warming and some reefs are dying and some cypress
forests are dying and hurricanes appear to be increasing in strength.
- Aerosols in the earth's atmosphere are changing, but they are hard
to measure. New, more accurate measuring devices are just coming on
line.
- The permafrost is melting, especially in northern Canada and Siberia.
Several
computer programs that integrate these measurements exist and they are
being tested. They show a climate-warming trend, but the earth does not
appear to have reached runaway. The accuracy of these programs is not
yet completely confirmed with data, but this accuracy is improving.
Is Action Required?
Many
still do not believe in climate warming. A counter theory has been
proposed. This theory says that the warming trend that we observe is due
to changes in solar radiation level and earth rotation axis wobble.
Since there is nothing we can do about these causes, these critics
propose that we do nothing that would upset the world economy, and wait
to see what happens. This procedure could be very dangerous, as we shall
see.
Suppose nothing is done. Then the following long-term bad effects are likely.
- The
glaciers are part of the earth's fresh water storage system. If they
disappear, the rivers will tend to flood in the winter and spring and
dry up in the summer.
- The ice shelves in the Arctic and Antarctic are excellent fish food
producers and if they disappear, this food source for fish may
disappear.
- If the mean sea level rises to its maximum, some of the most
important and valuable seacoast real estate in the world will be
submerged.
- If climate zones move north (and south), significant numbers of productive agricultural areas will be lost.
- If the oceans warm to the maximum, a large portion of the earth's
reefs will die, and many cypress forests will be damaged. This will
damage the associated fish breeding grounds. These problems will cause
the reduction of an important food source.
The above
effects have, for the most part, a limited bad impact on the earth's
livability. However, one impact of this cascade of events, the loss of
reflective ice and the melting and decay of the permafrost, may cause
runaway warming. Inaction would lock in all these bad effects and open
us to many future problems that are even worse. If runaway is possible
and something can be done, action now is absolutely required.
The Solution
A
practical and economically positive solution may be possible without
damaging the global economic system. This consists of an energy
generating system that can reduce carbon dioxide emission and sequester
the remainder. Specifically:
· Conservation, which would consist of substituting for fossil fuel power plants:
o Nuclear power plants where economical and safe
o Deep thermal well power plants where economical
o Ocean based wind and wave generators and solar cells to provide both base load energy and portable fuels.
o Electrical cars with solar cells to extend range.
o Alcohol and oil from waste wood, algae and kelp for portable power plant operations such as aircraft, trains, cars and trucks.
· Sequestering, which would consist of putting the carbon dioxide in the:
o Deep rock formations by use of deep thermal wells.
o Deep oceans by freezing the carbon dioxide and sinking it below the thermocline.
There
is a major problem with sequestering, however. Both the deep thermal
well and the ocean based wind and wave generators are being developed by
small companies that, under normal development procedures, would not be
expected to have a large impact for 30 years, and would not be expected
to start reversing the warming trend for 40 to 50 years. Now the ice
caps and the permafrost layers are expected to melt in 15 to 25 years.
Thus we may be in a state of runaway global warming before the solution
can come on line. Timing may be important.
Timing and the Overall Capability
This
situation contrasts with other green energy producers such as solar
cells. Solar cells have a serious production limit caused by a shortage
of both worker skills and refined solar cell materials, and could not
ramp up into the dominant energy producer in a timely fashion.
A
useful addition to the solution would be a process to sequester carbon
dioxide from the atmosphere, however there are no currently available
commercially viable ways to do this.
Conclusion
There
are steps that can be taken, however, that have a high probability of
success, and will have a positive effect of the economy. First, nuclear
plant construction should be supported wherever safety can be achieved
as a replacement for fossil fuel plants. Deep thermal well generator
development and construction should also be supported as a replacement
for fixed fossil fuel plants. Also, research for carbon dioxide
sequestration should be supported as well as any other commercially
viable alternate energy sources being developed now.
The
possibility of climate change due to carbon dioxide emission is
controversial. Many are not convinced that it exists. It cannot be
ignored, however. If it is ignored, there is a possibility that it will
turn into runaway global warming because of the thawing and decay of
permafrost vegetation, and the loss of the reflective ice caps.